Halloween is undoubtedly the most treat-centric holiday, and when we caught a glimpse of this milkshake on Instagram, we knew we had to investigate. Buns Bar in NYC has created a concoction to rival the likes of Black Tap, which has been the go-to for extravagant milkshakes. This one is made with salted caramel ice ream, homemade whipped cream, and cinnamon-dusted pumpkin fritters. It’s topped with a jack-o’-lantern cookie and candy corn pieces. The warm doughnuts were the perfect contrast to the cold ice cream, and the look of it alone got us even more excited for Oct. 31. Keep reading to see the most mouthwatering snaps of this ultimate Halloween dessert.